as proof, as evidence, as a girl可以用在句子开头吗?

Children love stories. As evidence/As proof, they fall asleep while listening to music.

请问as proof, as evidence在此处用法正确吗?

中国人把as翻译为“作为”,采用翻译的方法,“作为证据,孩子喜欢边听故事边入睡”看起来没什么问题。

从语法角度,这里as后面跟noun (phrase),修饰整个句子。The part of speech of as is connective or preposition.

Oxford English Dictionary有

9.
a. Introducing a clause modifying the whole main clause or some part other than its predicate: in accordance with what (is); in the way that.as men, things, etc., go: see go v. Phrases 3a(b).

as a rule: see rule n.1 Phrases 1h. as usual: see usual adj. 4d.

11.
a. Introducing a noun phrase equivalent to a subject or object complement.

所以,as+noun phrase不能修饰整个句子。

至于as a girl,根据11,as可以引导修饰主语的名词,或宾语补语。

但是9a有例外,如as a rule, as usual。

总的来说,as在句子开头,只能引导修饰主语的名词,或某些固定搭配。

发表评论

电子邮件地址不会被公开。

:wink: :twisted: :roll: :oops: :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :evil: :cry: :arrow: :?: :-| :-x :-o :-P :-D :-? :) :( :!: 8-O 8)